Showing posts with label Associated. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Associated. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 10, 2012

Pa. judge limits lawyer comments on Sandusky case - The Associated Press

AppId is over the quota
AppId is over the quota
Pa. judge limits lawyer comments on Sandusky caseBy MARK SCOLFORO, Associated Press – 9 hours ago?

HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — The judge overseeing the child sex abuse case against former Penn State assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky issued a gag order Monday that severely limits what attorneys on both sides may say to reporters.

Judge John Cleland's order also applies to any law enforcement investigator who has worked on the case and anyone acting on behalf of the lawyers.

The off-limit topics include evidence; opinions about Sandusky's guilt or innocence or about the merits of legal and factual matters under discussion; and "the reputation, character, credibility or criminal record of the defendant or any witness, prospective witness or organization which is or may testify at trial, or be the subject of trial testimony or evidence."

He directed the lawyers to "make reasonable efforts" to limit statements by witnesses or the witnesses' lawyers and to be able to prove they have taken those steps.

Cleland said he was acting to help ensure a "fair, impartial and orderly trial" for Sandusky, a proceeding scheduled to begin June 5 in Bellefonte.

Sandusky, 68, is charged with sexually abusing 10 boys over 15 years, and authorities say some of the abuse happened on Penn State's campus. Sandusky has maintained his innocence on the 52 counts against him.

The ensuing scandal led to the firing of legendary football coach Joe Paterno and the ouster of the university president.

Sandusky attorney Karl Rominger said he was studying the order.

"Having never been gagged by a court before, I will need to research the law and First Amendment issues," Rominger said in an email. "I'm pretty sure the court has the authority to limit press contacts, I just don't know what the law says about the scope and nature of such limits. Since the order does affect the media as well, I'll be curious to see if any press outlets appeal it."

A spokesman for the attorney general's office declined to comment.

Cleland said his order applies to comments that could reasonably be expected to be disseminated and to comments made on background or without attribution.

Lawyers on both sides have been speaking to banks of cameras and reporters after pretrial hearings at the Centre County Courthouse, a practice that is certain to be limited, if not ended outright, by the judge's order.

After a brief hearing on April 5, prosecutor Joe McGettigan was critical of the defense's tactics and responded to a defense claim that the charges lack specificity by telling reporters that Sandusky had been "provided with voluminous documentation of perversions against young children."

Cleland's order wasn't accompanied by any decisions regarding the defense motions that were the topic of last week's hearing, but the judge previously said he would decide on them this week.

Cleland wrote that the order was "narrowly tailored to achieve its purposes in light of the unprecedented publicity generated by the case" and that he will "broadly construe this order to assure that its purposes are achieved."

He also warned lawyers to comply with professional conduct rules regarding pretrial publicity, the special responsibilities of prosecutors and the state court system's code of civility.

Also awaiting trial are Gary Schultz and Tim Curley, Penn State administrators accused of lying to the grand jury investigating Sandusky and failing to properly report suspected child abuse. A Dauphin County judge on April 5 issued an order that set deadlines for various defense and prosecution filings, including catch-all defense motions by July 30, as well as a June 1 status conference on the case at a Harrisburg courthouse.

Curley, the school's athletic director, is on leave. Schultz, the former vice president for business and finance, has retired. Both have repeatedly denied the allegations.

Copyright ? 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.


View the original article here

Monday, March 26, 2012

Immunity in spotlight in NYC suit vs. Strauss-Kahn - The Associated Press

AppId is over the quota
AppId is over the quota
Immunity in spotlight in NYC suit vs. Strauss-KahnBy JENNIFER PELTZ, Associated Press – 4 hours ago?

NEW YORK (AP) — After criminal sexual assault charges against Dominique Strauss-Kahn dissolved last year in prosecutors' doubts about his accuser's reliability, she vowed to get her day in another court.

The hotel maid's civil case against the former International Monetary Fund chief is now nearing an important point, with a hearing set this week on Strauss-Kahn's claim that diplomatic immunity should insulate him from the lawsuit.

The hearing, the first in the case, isn't intended to weigh the essence of housekeeper Nafissatou Diallo's allegation that Strauss-Kahn tried to rape her when she arrived to clean his luxury suite last May. The accusation put Strauss-Kahn, then a potential French presidential candidate, in jail for nearly a week and launched his political career into a tailspin of sexual scandal.

Rather, Wednesday's hearing is likely to revolve around the complex laws that shield diplomats from prosecution and lawsuits in their host countries. And Strauss-Kahn's arguments are raising some novel questions about the scope of those laws, experts say.

"This is a very unique set of circumstances, and high-profile, to boot," said Robert C. O'Brien, a former United Nations official who is now the managing partner of Arent Fox LLP's Los Angeles office.

Neither Diallo, 33, nor Strauss-Kahn, 62, is expected to attend the hearing in a Bronx state court. It's unclear when a judge will decide whether the case should be allowed to go forward toward a trial, which Diallo's lawyers say she eagerly awaits.

"It didn't happen with the DA, but we intend to vindicate Ms. Diallo's rights," one of her lawyers, Kenneth P. Thompson, said by phone.

Strauss-Kahn's lawyers declined to comment. They've previously slammed the suit as an attempt to squeeze money out of him.

Then overseeing the IMF, Strauss-Kahn was in New York to visit his daughter when Diallo said he attacked her. The married Strauss-Kahn has since called the encounter a "moral failing" but insists it wasn't violent.

The Manhattan district attorney's office dropped the case in August, saying prosecutors couldn't proceed on the word of a woman who had lied about her background and wavered about her actions right after the alleged attack. Diallo is adamant that she was truthful about the encounter.

The Associated Press generally doesn't name people who report being sexually assaulted unless they come forward publicly, as Diallo has done.

When police arrested him, Strauss-Kahn declared that he had diplomatic immunity, according to a police account of his statements. But the IMF soon said he didn't because he was in New York on personal business. Strauss-Kahn, who resigned his post days later, ultimately didn't try to assert immunity in the criminal case.

His lawyers have said he was focused then on clearing his name but is claiming immunity now because he doesn't want to have to defend himself further against the same allegations.

Giving foreign countries' representatives a legal pass, to show respect and further diplomacy, is an ancient tradition codified in various modern laws.

Strauss-Kahn argues he had complete immunity — including for personal activities — under a 1947 U.N. agreement that afforded that privilege to the heads of "specialized agencies," which include the IMF. Strauss-Kahn carried a diplomatic travel document saying he was entitled to those immunities, his lawyers note.

The United States isn't part of the 1947 agreement. But Strauss-Kahn's lawyers contend that it has such widespread acceptance elsewhere that it has become what's known as "customary international law," a principle U.S. courts have recognized.

"Mr. Strauss-Kahn enjoyed absolute immunity under customary international law," even after he resigned the IMF post but was required to stay in the United States for the criminal case, lawyer William W. Taylor III wrote in a September court filing calling for the suit to be dismissed.

Diallo's lawyers responded that Strauss-Kahn's argument "misses the mark completely." It's overreaching to claim that the 1947 agreement amounts to an international norm, especially in a country that didn't sign onto it, and the IMF flatly said Strauss-Kahn didn't have immunity, Thompson wrote in a filing in October.

If the case survives, it will test Diallo's claims in a forum with considerably different rules than criminal court.

Prosecutors in criminal cases must prove a case beyond a reasonable doubt, while plaintiffs in lawsuits need only persuade a judge or jury that a preponderance of the evidence is in their favor. And a defendant can be forced to testify in a civil case, unlike in a criminal one.

The former criminal case against Strauss-Kahn could factor in the civil case, however. Diallo's lawyers likely would try to introduce the fact that Strauss-Kahn was criminally charged. And his attorneys could try to raise the inconsistencies in her statements to prosecutors, said Robert Mintz, a former federal prosecutor in New Jersey who's now a defense lawyer with McCarter & English LLP.

Since his arrest, Strauss-Kahn has been mired in other allegations surrounding his sex life.

A French writer came forward to say he'd tried to rape her during a 2003 interview; Paris prosecutors said in October that the case was too old to try, but they said Strauss-Kahn had admitted during questioning to actions amounting to sexual assault.

Then he was questioned by police in Lille, France, last month about a suspected hotel prostitution ring.

Diallo, meanwhile, has struggled with psychological and physical aftereffects of her encounter with Strauss-Kahn, Thompson said. She said a ligament in her shoulder was torn, among other injuries.

She hasn't returned to work or even gone back to the hotel since, her lawyer said.

Follow Jennifer Peltz at http://twitter.com/jennpeltz

Copyright ? 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.


View the original article here

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

Lawyer: San Francisco sheriff won't resign - The Associated Press

IP is over the quota
IP is over the quota
Lawyer: San Francisco sheriff won't resignBy PAUL ELIAS, Associated Press – 1 day ago?

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — A lawyer for San Francisco's sheriff said Tuesday he has no plans to resign despite the threat of an ethics probe over a domestic violence case.

Attorney Lidia Stiglich told The Associated Press that Sheriff Ross Mirkarimi was asked by Mayor Ed Lee to step down after pleading guilty to a misdemeanor count of false imprisonment.

"I'm not aware of any plans for the sheriff to resign," Stiglich said. "I'm disappointed it's proceeding in this fashion. I think it should be left to the voters."

The charge stemmed from a New Year's Eve dispute with his wife in which her arm was bruised.

The sheriff met with Lee after his sentencing Monday. During that discussion, Lee gave him 24 hours to resign or face an ethics charge that could result in his removal from office.

Lee has declined to comment on the matter but said he would make an announcement later Tuesday.

A judge sentenced Mirkarimi to three years of probation and ordered him to attend anti-domestic violence counseling for a year.

Mirkarimi entered the plea in exchange for the dropping of three other misdemeanor charges of domestic violence, child endangerment and dissuading a witness.

Lee can start the process of removing Mirkarimi, but it would take the votes of nine of the 11 members of the Board of Supervisors to accomplish that task. The matter would first be referred to the city's Ethics Commission if Lee decides to push for removal.

After the brief meeting at City Hall on Monday, Mirkarimi left the mayor's office via a back door and a rarely used staircase to get to his office. He said he had no comment when tracked down by reporters.

The plea deal was struck as a jury was picked for a trial that promised to embarrass the sheriff with testimony about infidelity, his temper and other intimate details.

San Francisco District Attorney George Gascon said the false imprisonment charge was a domestic violence plea and the conviction was just as serious as the charges that were dropped.

Under the plea agreement, Mirkarimi must pay $590 in fines, serve probation, spend a year in a domestic violence intervention program, take parenting classes and do community service.

The district attorney said Mirkarimi will be barred from carrying a gun until a judge lifts a stay-away order still in place that prevents the sheriff from seeing his wife without court permission. Gascon said that order could stay in place for the entire three years of probation.

Mirkarimi also said he was undergoing counseling to address "my arrogance and anger management issues" and reiterated his advocacy against domestic violence while serving two-terms on the Board of Supervisors.

Copyright ? 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.


View the original article here

Lawyer: San Francisco sheriff won't resign - The Associated Press

AppId is over the quota
AppId is over the quota
Lawyer: San Francisco sheriff won't resignBy PAUL ELIAS, Associated Press – 3 hours ago?

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — A lawyer for San Francisco's sheriff said Tuesday he has no plans to resign despite the threat of an ethics probe over a domestic violence case.

Attorney Lidia Stiglich told The Associated Press that Sheriff Ross Mirkarimi was asked by Mayor Ed Lee to step down after pleading guilty to a misdemeanor count of false imprisonment.

"I'm not aware of any plans for the sheriff to resign," Stiglich said. "I'm disappointed it's proceeding in this fashion. I think it should be left to the voters."

The charge stemmed from a New Year's Eve dispute with his wife in which her arm was bruised.

The sheriff met with Lee after his sentencing Monday. During that discussion, Lee gave him 24 hours to resign or face an ethics charge that could result in his removal from office.

Lee has declined to comment on the matter but said he would make an announcement later Tuesday.

A judge sentenced Mirkarimi to three years of probation and ordered him to attend anti-domestic violence counseling for a year.

Mirkarimi entered the plea in exchange for the dropping of three other misdemeanor charges of domestic violence, child endangerment and dissuading a witness.

Lee can start the process of removing Mirkarimi, but it would take the votes of nine of the 11 members of the Board of Supervisors to accomplish that task. The matter would first be referred to the city's Ethics Commission if Lee decides to push for removal.

After the brief meeting at City Hall on Monday, Mirkarimi left the mayor's office via a back door and a rarely used staircase to get to his office. He said he had no comment when tracked down by reporters.

The plea deal was struck as a jury was picked for a trial that promised to embarrass the sheriff with testimony about infidelity, his temper and other intimate details.

San Francisco District Attorney George Gascon said the false imprisonment charge was a domestic violence plea and the conviction was just as serious as the charges that were dropped.

Under the plea agreement, Mirkarimi must pay $590 in fines, serve probation, spend a year in a domestic violence intervention program, take parenting classes and do community service.

The district attorney said Mirkarimi will be barred from carrying a gun until a judge lifts a stay-away order still in place that prevents the sheriff from seeing his wife without court permission. Gascon said that order could stay in place for the entire three years of probation.

Mirkarimi also said he was undergoing counseling to address "my arrogance and anger management issues" and reiterated his advocacy against domestic violence while serving two-terms on the Board of Supervisors.

Copyright ? 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.


View the original article here

Judge gives Sandusky lawyer accusers' contact info - The Associated Press

AppId is over the quota
AppId is over the quota
Judge gives Sandusky lawyer accusers' contact infoBy MARK SCOLFORO, Associated Press – 5 hours ago?

HARRISBURG, Pa. (AP) — Prosecutors on Tuesday were ordered to give Jerry Sandusky's lawyer the phone numbers and addresses of those who have accused the former Penn State assistant football coach of child sex abuse.

It was a pretrial win for Sandusky's lawyer, Joe Amendola, who argued in a filing late last week that it would be very difficult for defense investigators to locate and try to interview them without first getting contact information from prosecutors. The order also extends to the phone numbers and addresses of the accusers when the crimes are alleged to have occurred.

The order by Judge John Cleland could also lead to the prosecution turning over any psychological evaluations performed on the accusers, but the attorney general's office was given another week to try to persuade him they are protected by legal privilege and not subject to disclosure.

The psychological evaluations would be produced under seal, and Amendola wouldn't be allowed to do more than read them without getting the judge's prior approval.

Amendola is specifically seeking a psychologist's report related to a person described as Victim 6 in a grand jury report, saying he believes it contains a conclusion that Sandusky didn't sexually abuse the boy. The grand jury said Victim 6's mother complained to authorities after he showered with Sandusky in 1998. The subsequent investigation by Penn State police didn't result in any charges.

Ben Andreozzi, the lawyer for another accuser, said Amendola was trying to put the victims on trial and create distractions. He said Amendola "knows better than to contact my client."

"Mr. Sandusky knows what he did to these young men, so he would be wise not to challenge the veracity of their allegations at trial," Andreozzi said. "Instead, I anticipate he will continue to raise irrelevant issues while grasping at straws, trying to create reasonable doubt."

Amendola said he was only seeking information he was legally entitled to as he prepares a defense for Sandusky, who has maintained his innocence from the outset. The 68-year-old Sandusky awaits a scheduled mid-May start of trial on 52 criminal counts. Prosecutors say he sexually abused 10 boys over 15 years.

Cleland required prosecutors to disclose juvenile adjudication records that might help Amendola attack the credibility of any witness the state plans to call at trial.

That does not apply to drug or alcohol violations, however, and Amendola had argued that several accusers used drugs and alcohol as juveniles, which he said might affect their ability to testify accurately.

Cleland's order said requests for grand jury information must first be made to the judge who oversees the secret panel. If that judge says grand jury secrecy prevents their release, Cleland said he intends to abide by that decision. Otherwise, Cleland said, he will reconsider Amendola's request.

A spokesman for the attorney general's office declined to comment on the latest filing.

Copyright ? 2012 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.


View the original article here