AppId is over the quota
Prominent Maori lawyer Donna Hall has denied a conflict of interest over a central North Island land deal in which she allegedly acted for three of the trusts involved in the sale.
The Law Society's standards committee alleges Ms Hall acted for the vendor, purchaser and lender during the 2007 deal, without the consent of each party to represent the others.
The committee opened its case against Ms Hall before the Lawyers and Conveyancers Disciplinary Tribunal in Wellington today.
The tribunal is able to impose much harsher sanctions than the committee can, including being struck off the roll, suspension, or fines of up to $30,000.
The hearing follows a complaint from a shareholder of the Tauhara Middle 15 Trust, which in 2007 bought the Tauhara North block near Taupo from Landcorp for $5 million jointly with another trust.
The complainant alleged a conflict because Ms Hall acted for both Tauhara and the Hikuwai Hapu Lands Trust, which facilitated the transaction.
She also acted for Tauhara Middle 4A2A Trust, which provided an unsecured loan to Tauhara Middle 15 to help fund its $1m contribution to the deal.
Law Society standards committee lawyer Gary Turkington told the tribunal today that Ms Hall failed to advise each party of the areas of conflict or potential conflict, and to advise the purchaser and lender that each should take independent advice.
Ms Hall was in a conflicted position during the on-selling of the land because she was also acting for the purchasing trust, he said.
In authorising the sale, the Maori Land Court gave its approval for the execution of a mortgage, but signalled it was not approving the purchase until five questions had been answered.
Mr Turkington said Ms Hall by-passed the questions and had put Hikuwai's trustees first.
Ms Hall's lawyer, Helen Cull, said there was no conflict because her client was not acting on the land deal itself.
Rather, she was acting on behalf of the Tauhara Middle 15 in its Maori Land Court proceedings, and to help remove a trustee who was opposed to the bank loan to secure the deal.
Ms Cull said the trust had approached Ms Hall to act on its behalf in the land deal, but she declined and instructed a barrister to act for the trust.
It was the barrister's duty to inform the trustees of a potential conflict, and any conflict arose from the trusts sharing trustees, she said.
Three people involved in the deal were trustees on all three trusts, while a further three were trustees on the two Tauhara trusts.
Ms Cull said there was evidence the trusts had shared mutual interests in purchasing the land, which had significant development potential for Maori, and the trusts shared beneficiaries.
"It is only a professional conflict if there are two distinctive interests that are conflicting and we don't accept that,'' she said.
Tribunal member Susan Hughes QC questioned whether the trustees were aware that Ms Hall stood to lose $300,000 in legal fees from the Hikuwai trust if the deal did not got through.
Ms Cull said she would need to take instructions from her client on that matter, and would get back to the tribunal tomorrow.
The hearing is expected to last three days.
- APNZ
By Hana Garrett-Walker and Matthew Backhouse | Email Hana
PersonalizeThe Washington PostD.C. MarylandVirginiaCrimeEducationOn Faith/LocalObituariesTraffic & CommutingWeatherBlogs & ColumnsThe Root DCIn the NewsFreeze watch Death threat Md. privatization Montgomery transit Milloy apology ???initialComments:true! pubdate:03/24/2012 10:34 EDT! commentPeriod:14! commentEndDate:4/7/12 10:34 EDT! currentDate:3/25/12 8:0 EDT! allowComments:true! displayComments:true!
Behind the scenes at the White House
The art and innovation of the real ‘Mad Men’
Venus and Jupiter, meet the moon
Climbing to the top of the National CathedralJohn Payton, a lawyer who argued bias cases before Supreme Court, dies at 65
Text SizePrintE-mailReprints By T. Rees Shapiro, The Washington Post
(Alex Brandon/ASSOCIATED PRESS) - NAACP Legal Defense and Education Fund President and Director-Counsel John Payton died March 22 at Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore. He was 65.
The Post Most: LocalMost-viewed stories, videos and galleries int he past two hoursMost PopularBatman pulled over in Silver SpringIndian Sikhs in Loudoun say death threat is a rarity amid lives of suburban successFive universities that really are up-and-comersFreeze watch Monday night for most of Washington, D.C. areaApologies to black fathersTop VideosAA flight attendant's 9/11 rant (0:56)Protests nationwide over birth control mandate (1:36)John Kelly's home movies (0:57)D.C. cherry blossoms blooming early (2:12)Apple store footage during Lululemon murder (3:12)Top GalleriesClimbing to the top of the National CathedralDeath threat shocks Loudoun's SikhsD.C.'s cherry blossomsNonbelievers rally in D.C. for recognition, respectNorwood sentenced to life in prison in Lululemon killing
Featured Advertiser Links
for L U N G C A N C E R V I C T I M S>>
HIP REPLACEMENT -- did you get one after '03?>>Help Barack stand up for working Americans. Join our campaign now.>>The only candidate fighting for the middle class: Pres. Obama. Join us.>>Sign up for email updates from President Obama's 2012 campaign.>>Sign up for official email updates from Barack Obama's campaign.>>Looking to buy a home? Visit TWP Real Estate section for the latest open houses.>>Make Your Vanguard Investing More Profitable - Free Research Report Reveals Best & Worst Funds>>Top local Stories People Also ReadMost Popular Videos
Batman pulled over in Silver SpringKatie Rogers?
Indian Sikhs in Loudoun say death threat is rarity amid lives of suburban successPamela Constable?
Five universities that really are up-and-comersDaniel De Vise?Freeze watch Monday night for most of Washington, D.C. areaJason Samenow?Apologies to black fathersCourtland Milloy?4 killed in Route 50 crash::unspecified::?‘There is no joy in education these days’Valerie Strauss?
Task force: Montgomery County rapid bus system to require property tax increaseVictor Zapana?Bag fee dead in Prince George’sMiranda S. Spivack?
Bill would let Maryland seek out private partners for public projectsAaron C. Davis?What the latest revelations on test cheating really meanValerie Strauss?Defense Dept.’s longest-serving general and African American retiresVa. governor’s chef leaves amid investigationAnita Kumar?Motorists scoop up armored car money, in scene witness calls ‘snow globe of cash’Dan Morse?NASA waits for clear skies to launch rockets from Wallops IslandMartin Weil?Ignoring a reform that worksValerie Strauss?Answer Man solves the mystery of the sad Shirlington buildingJohn Kelly?Brittany Norwood receives life, no parole, for killing Jayna Murray in Lululemon yoga storePaul Duggan?For CIA family, a deadly suicide bombing leads to painful divisionsIan Shapira?Fairfax teacher placed on leaveEmma Brown?
Ways you can get us Mobile Apps Newsletter & alerts RSS Post Store Facebook Washington Post Live Twitter The Washington Post Work for us Community Relations PostPoints Corrections/Suggestions Archive Contact the Ombudsman Report a problem Web site Make us your homepage Digital Guidelines Ask The Post Newspaper Subscribe Home delivery service e-Replica Advertise In the newspaper On the web site Mobile Events The Washington Post Company Post Company web sites Partners Slate Express Night Out Captial Business El Tiempo Latino The Root Foreign Policy Trove Post Tickets Capitol Deal Service Alley Post Master Class WP Live Student Advisor College Reviews ? 1996- The Washington Post Terms of Service Privacy Policy Reprints and Permissions RSS Terms of Service Help Contact Us Ad Choices Section:/local/obituaries
Behind the scenes at the White House
10 ways Washingtonians are better (or worse)
Photos: Marching for Trayvon
Your photos: Spring is in bloomJohn Payton, a lawyer who argued bias cases before Supreme Court, dies at 65
Demonstrators at Freedom Plaza rally in memory of Trayvon MartinOvetta Wiggins?
Batman pulled over in Silver SpringKatie Rogers?
Loudoun County in hot seat on approving Metro’s Silver Line decisionFredrick Kunkle; Caitlin Gibson?
2 teens killed in crash after police pursuit through Chevy ChaseDan Morse; Erica W. Morrison?Trayvon Martin rally in D.C.: Live tweetsKatie Rogers?
Mansion chef departs amid police investigationAnita Kumar?
Reason Rally on the Mall is a milestone event for the growing atheist movementRick Wingrove?Forecast: Showers and some rumbles possible through the weekendIan Livingston?Newborn’s death ruled homicide, police sayMartin Weil?Defense Dept.’s longest-serving general and African American retires
Redskins talk gets cold reception in Hill EastMike Debonis?John Payton, a lawyer who argued bias cases before Supreme Court, dies at 65T. Rees Shapiro?Attack in NW Washington Rec CenterClarence Williams?Maryland House passes budget, setting up a debate with Senate over size of tax hikeAaron C. Davis?
Five universities that really are up-and-comersDaniel De Vise?Motorists scoop up armored car money, in scene witness calls ‘snow globe of cash’Dan Morse?
Transformer explosion damages one carWashington Post Editors?In Texas, a revolt brews against standardized testingValerie Strauss?What would a 0.5 percent raise mean?::unspecified::?Amid Trayvon Martin killing, Hill staffers gather to shine a brighter light on racial profilingRachel S. Karas?