per-lawyer: Government lawyer defends prosecution of NY jury nullification proponent, says ...

IP is over the quota
IP is over the quota
Government lawyer defends prosecution of NY jury nullification proponent, says he’s a ‘threat’ - The Washington Post Print SubscriptionConversationsToday's PaperGoing Out GuideJobsCarsReal EstateRentalsClassifiedsShoppingHomePoliticsCampaign 2012CongressCourts &LawThe Fed PageHealth CarePollingWhite HouseBlogs & ColumnsIssues: EnergyTop Blogs

Election 2012 | Felicia SonmezThe Fix | Chris CillizzaFederal Eye | Ed O’KeefeFact Checker | Glenn KesslerOpinionsAll OpinionsPostPartisanLeft-LeaningRight-LeaningTolesCartoonsTelnaesAnimationsLocalColumnist IndexLocalDC: Politics| NewsMD: Politics| CommunitiesVA: Politics| CommunitiesCrimeEducationOn Faith/LocalObituariesTraffic & CommutingWeatherBlogs & ColumnsThe Root DCTop Blogs

Post NowThe BuzzCapital Weather GangDr. GridlockSportsRedskins/NFLCapitals/NHLWizards/NBANationals/MLBDC United/SoccerCollegesAllMetSportsOther SportsBlogs & ColumnsTop Blogs

The Insider| Mike JonesCapitals Insider| Katie CarreraWizards Insider | Michael LeeNationals Journal| Adam KilgoreNationalCorrectionsEnergy & EnvironmentHealth & ScienceHigher EducationNational SecurityOn FaithOn LeadershipInnovationsOn GivingBlogs & ColumnsTop Blogs

Ideas@InnovationsPost LeadershipUnder GodCheckpoint WashingtonWorldAfricaTheAmericasAsia &PacificEuropeMiddle EastNational SecurityWar ZonesSpecial ReportsCheckpoint WashingtonBusinessEconomyIndustriesLocal BusinessMarketsPolicy&RegulationTechnologyWorldBusinessBlogs & ColumnsInnovationsOn Small BusinessTop Blogs

Wonkblog | Ezra KleinPost Tech | Cecilia KangFaster ForwardWhere We LiveInvestigationsLifestyleAdviceCarolyn HaxFoodHome & GardenStyleTravelWeddingsWellnessMagazineKidsPostTop Blogs

The Style BlogAll We Can EatReliable Source | Roxanne Roberts & Amy ArgetsingerOn Parenting | Janice D’ArcyEntertainmentBooksCelebritiesComicsGoing Out GuideHoroscopesMoviesMuseumsPuzzlesTheater & DanceTVTop Blogs

TV Column | Lisa de MoraesCelebritology | Jen ChaneyComic Riffs | Michael CavnaClassical Beat | Anne MidgetteMultimediaInnovationsPhotosVideosThe Washington PostThe Washington PostCorrectionsEnergy & EnvironmentHealth & ScienceHigher EducationNational SecurityOn FaithOn LeadershipInnovationsOn GivingBlogs & ColumnsIn the NewsMitt Romney New iPad Tebow trade ‘Hunger Games’ Trayvon Martin ???initialComments:true! pubdate:03/21/2012 20:52 EDT! commentPeriod:14! commentEndDate:4/4/12 8:52 EDT! currentDate:3/21/12 8:0 EDT! allowComments:true! displayComments:true!

Your photos: Spring is in bloom

Readers say: ‘I wish I had said...’

‘Hunger Games’ 101

Your best cherry blossom photos

Government lawyer defends prosecution of NY jury nullification proponent, says he’s a ‘threat’

Text SizePrintE-mailReprints By Associated Press, AP

NEW YORK — A government lawyer on Wednesday vigorously defended the prosecution of a man who urges jurors to sometimes disregard the law and vote their conscience, calling him a “significant threat” to the integrity of the judicial system.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Rebecca Mermelstein argued before U.S. District Judge Kimba Wood in an unusual court case that tests whether the First Amendment can shield the actions of Julian Heicklen. Heicklen was arrested and charged with a misdemeanor for repeatedly handing out pamphlets to people outside a lower Manhattan courthouse near the World Trade Center site between October 2009 and May 2010, urging a practice known in legal circles as jury nullification.

Comments

Weigh InCorrections?

Personal Post

Mermelstein said in court papers that Heicklen, who was indicted on Nov. 18, 2010, also has regularly passed out pamphlets in front of federal courthouses in Philadelphia, Boston, Tampa, Fla., Alexandria, Va., Concord, N.H., Springfield, Mass., Hartford, Conn., and Albany and White Plains in New York state.

“It’s the content of the message that’s undermining the fairness of the legal system in this courthouse,” Mermelstein said. “It’s a significant threat.”

Mermelstein said Heicklen had written on the Tyrranyfighters website that “jury nullification has born fruit in a recent case in Missoula, Montana due to the jurors’ indications during voir dire that they would not convict a defendant of the entirely victimless act of possession of 1 1/16 of an ounce of marijuana.”

She said that if Heicklen were permitted to continue, then judges might as well instruct jurors: “Here’s the law, but do whatever you want.”

Heicklen, who is representing himself against the criminal charge of improperly trying to influence a juror, did not argue before the judge and was not in court. Instead, two public defenders were appointed to represent his interests in the oral arguments. The judge did not immediately rule.

Attorney Steven M. Statsinger said Heicklen was within his rights because the plaza outside the federal courthouse in lower Manhattan is a public forum and he is not trying to influence any particular jurors in any ongoing cases.

“There’s no corrupt intent to undermine the outcome of a particular case,” the lawyer said.

Statsinger said Heicklen’s actions would be comparable to someone telling potential witnesses that they have the Fifth Amendment right not to say anything.

Mermelstein, the prosecutor, noted that other judges had already ruled that the area immediately outside the courthouse was not a public forum, though she said nearby areas such as the streets of Chinatown might be fine.

Heicklen was arrested after he passed out pamphlets on at least eight occasions while he carried a sign reading “Jury Info.”

In court papers, Statsinger and another lawyer, Sabrina Schroff, said Heicklen’s conduct does not offend the judicial system. They are seeking a jury trial for Heicklen.

“The sight of a shabby old man distributing his silly leaflets from the sidewalk outside of a courthouse ... is, at its worst, an inconvenience or an annoyance,” they wrote.

EmailTumblrRedditStumbleuponDiggDeliciousDiscussion Policy | FAQ | About DiscussionsLoading...

Comments

Add your comment
Read about the changes to comment thread appearance, moderation. ?Read what others are sayingAbout Badges SuperFan Badge

SuperFan badge holders consistently post smart, timely comments about Washington area sports and teams.